Season 1

Jan. 24, 2021

Adam Walsh // Florida // 47

Adam John Walsh disappeared from a the mall in Hollywood, Florida on the afternoon of July 27th, 1981. He was six years old and it's believed that he got kicked out of the Sears store with a group of older boys. On August 1...

Listen to the episode

Jan. 17, 2021

Bear Brook murders // New Hampshire // 46

The Bear Brook murders or the Allentown four, is a case where, we know who the serial killer is, before we know who the victims are. An adult female and 3 female children were discovered in barrels. The murderer is Terry Ra...

Listen to the episode

Jan. 10, 2021

John Wayne Gacy // Illinois // 45 // Part 3

John Wayne Gacy confessed everything to his lawyer and police obtained another search warrant for Gacy's home. Bodies were discovered all over the house and he ended up being sentenced to death. If you think the execution i...

Listen to the episode

Jan. 3, 2021

John Wayne Gacy // Illinois // 44 // Part 2

This story starts with John Wayne Gacy's torture and murders. Several boys that knew Gacy, just disappeared. At first, the police didn't believe Gacy was involved and he had no problem talking to them. The police got a search...

Listen to the episode

Dec. 27, 2020

John Wayne Gacy // Illinois // 43 // Part 1

John Wayne Gacy grew up with an alcoholic father who beat him and when he got old enough to leave, he drove to Las Vegas and became an attendant at a funeral home for three months, but he had to dip because he climbed into a ...

Listen to the episode

Dec. 20, 2020

Chowchilla kidnapping // California // 42

A whole entire bus, 26 kids, and their bus driver, Ed, disappeared in California in 1976. Three gunmen loaded on the bus and took it over, Resulting in one of the largest mass kidnappings in U.S. history. You won't want to mi...

Listen to the episode

Dec. 13, 2020

Katie Poirier // Minnesota // 41

On May 26th, 1999, 19-year-old Katie Poirier was abducted while working at DJ's Expressway. This convenience store was located near Interstate 35, on the outskirts of Moose Lake, Minnesota. The store had four surveillance ...

Listen to the episode

Dec. 6, 2020

Ashley Freeman and Lauria Bible // Oklahoma // 40

On December 29th, 1999, Lauria Bible celebrated her friend, Ashley Freeman's 16th birthday. The girls spent the day together and ended up having a sleepover that night. Somewhere between the hours of 5:30 to 6:00 AM on Dece...

Listen to the episode

Nov. 29, 2020

Michael Malloy // New York // 39

In 1932, there was an Irish man named Michael Malloy and the WHOLE town decided he had to die. They figured they could get the life insurance money and split it. The local bar began giving free drinks to Malloy and the big ma...

Listen to the episode

Nov. 22, 2020

Tracey Kirkpatrick // Maryland // 38

Tracey Kirkpatrick was a quiet teenager who lived in the small town of Frederick, Maryland. On the night of March 15th, 1989, Tracey was scheduled to close the store she worked at, Aileen Ladies Sportswear. Around 10:30 PM,...

Listen to the episode

Nov. 15, 2020

Cathy Moulton // Maine // 37

On the evening of September 24th, 1971, Cathy Moulton was planning to attend a YWCA dance. She went on a shopping trip to pick up pantyhose and toothpaste, but never made it back home. Cathy was initially classified as a runa...

Listen to the episode

Nov. 8, 2020

John and Nancy Bosco // Montana // 36

On August 12th 1993, John and Nancy Bosco were murdered in their home in Ferndale, Montana. The crime scene was bloody and confusing. John appeared to be more decomposed than Nancy and police initially thought this could be a...

Listen to the episode

Oct. 31, 2020

Gypsy Rose and Dee Dee Blanchard // Missouri // 35

Gypsy Rose was suffering from leukemia and muscular dystrophy when she was just 8-years-old. She required a wheelchair, oxygen tanks, and a feeding tube. She also had seizures, asthma, hearing loss and visual impairments. Her...

Listen to the episode

Oct. 24, 2020

Dybbuk Box // 34

You just may rethink buying something from an estate sale after you hear the story of the Dybbuk box. Poor, Kevin Mannis learned that sometimes items that had previous owners, come with a little extra spirit. Malicious spi...

Listen to the episode

Oct. 18, 2020

Annabelle doll // 33

Annabelle is an allegedly haunted doll that is in the occult museum of the paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren. According to the Warren's, a student nurse was given the doll in 1970. Like me, you may have believed...

Listen to the episode

Oct. 11, 2020

Winchester Mystery House // 32

The Winchester Mystery House is a mansion in San Jose, California. It's well known for its size, architectural oddities, and lack of plan when it was built. Many people simply believe that Sarah Winchester was so distraught o...

Listen to the episode

Oct. 4, 2020

Robert the Doll // 31

Robert Eugene Otto or, Gene, as everyone called him, was just 10 years old when he was given a doll that he named, Robert. Robert is child sized, made out of a cork like material, he wears a sailor outfit that was Genes as a ...

Listen to the episode

Sept. 27, 2020

Amy Mihaljevic // Ohio // 30

On October 27th, 1989, Amy Mihaljevic was kidnapped from the Bay Village Square Shopping Center in Bay Village, Ohio. Amy had been contacted by telephone and believed she would be meeting someone to buy a secret gift for her ...

Listen to the episode

Sept. 20, 2020

Jeremy Bright // Oregon // 29

Jeremy Doland Bright was born May 25th 1972 and he disappeared August 14th 1986. Jeremy's disappearance happened under very mysterious circumstances while attending the Coos County Fair in Myrtle Point, Oregon. Jeremy lived i...

Listen to the episode

Sept. 13, 2020

Mary Lynn Witherspoon // South Carolina // 28

Mary Lynn Witherspoon lived in South Carolina and was stalked for over two decades by her ex-boyfriend's son, Tennent Brown the fourth. Many people warned Mary Lynn over the years that she should get a restraining order, but ...

Listen to the episode

Sept. 6, 2020

The Staircase // North Carolina // 27

On December 9th, 2001, Michael Peterson placed a call to 911 to report that his wife had an accident and fell down the stairs. Kathleen Peterson was lying at the bottom of a staircase in their Durham, North Carolina mansion a...

Listen to the episode

Aug. 30, 2020

Delphi murders // Indiana // 26

On February 14th, 2017, the bodies of 13-year-old Abigail Williams and 14-year-old Liberty German were discovered near the Monon High Bridge Trail, which is part of the Delphi Historic Trails in Delphi, Indiana. A photo and ...

Listen to the episode

Aug. 23, 2020

Billy the Kid // New Mexico // 25

Billy the Kid went by several different names throughout his life. The year he was born, the places he lived and the year he died have all been disputed over the years. Billy the Kid participated in the Battle of Lincoln in...

Listen to the episode

Aug. 16, 2020

Christi Jo Nichols // Nebraska // 24

Christi Jo met Mark Nichols when she was 19-years-old, they got married and had two children. Rumors began swirling that the couple was having marital problems and Mark was allegedly abusing Christi. Mark discovered that Ch...

Listen to the episode

July 26, 2020

Briley Brothers // Virginia // 23

The three Briley brothers, Linwood, James Jr., and Anthony were polite and helpful to their neighbors. At school, it was a different story. They harassed and bullied the others. In 1971, Linwood committed his first killing...

Listen to the episode

July 19, 2020

Eric Robert // South Dakota // 22

Eric Robert posed as a police officer, pulled over an 18-year-old woman and forced her into the trunk of his car. He heard her talking to someone on her cellphone and ended up fleeing, but was convicted and sentenced to 80 y...

Listen to the episode

July 19, 2020

Susan Cox Powell // Utah // 21

Joshua Powell and Susan Cox Powell got married in 2001 and had two sons, Charles and Braden. Over the years, Susan began indicating that the marriage was quite troubled. The entire Powell family was reported missing on Dece...

Listen to the episode

July 19, 2020

Christine Cole // Rhode Island // 20

Christine Cole left her home to buy groceries for her mother two days after her 10th birthday. Her body was discovered 54 days later and the case remained unsolved for more than three decades. After the case was reopened in...

Listen to the episode

July 15, 2020

Sodder Children Disappearance // West Virginia // 19

On December 24th, 1945, a fire destroyed the Sodder home in Fayetteville, West Virginia. There were eleven people residing in the home that night and and six of them made it out alive. The bodies of five children disappeare...

Listen to the episode

July 7, 2020

Slender Man // Wisconsin // 18

Slender Man is a fictional supernatural character. He is depicted as thin, unnaturally tall, with long, tentacle-like arms, a featureless head and face, and he wears a black suit. It's just an internet meme that pops up in ...

Listen to the episode

July 6, 2020

Lizzie Borden // Massachusetts // 17

Lizzie Borden's family had a lot of money, but they lived in a small, shabby home. Lizzie may have been mentally disturbed and was known to be a kleptomaniac. Besides this, she seemed to be a fairly normal girl. On August ...

Listen to the episode

June 27, 2020

Jodi Arias // Arizona // 16

As usual, Megan had weird dreams again. After we move past the catfisher in the closet, we jump right into our story. Travis Alexander was murdered in his bathroom in Mesa, Arizona. He was stabbed between 27 and 29 times, s...

Listen to the episode

June 22, 2020

The Boys on the Tracks // Arkansas // Part 2 // 15

In part two of The Boys on the Tracks, the bodies were exhumed for a new autopsy and it changed the investigation to homicide. A former wrestler, Billy Jack Haynes, says he witnessed the murders of Kevin Ives and Don Henry. H...

Listen to the episode

June 14, 2020

The Boys on the Tracks // Arkansas // Part 1 // 14

You guys, poor baby Monster kitty's ear fell off!!! Alright, it was just a dream, but it was still scary! We'll bring you plenty of ridiculous stories this week. Hanna ran around drunk with horses and Megan fell down, died an...

Listen to the episode

June 14, 2020

NXIVM // New York // 13

You Can't miss this week's episode! Hanna decided to be super sneaky and surprise, Megan, for her belated birthday....and only 2 days short of a month late! The only thing we will tell you, is that it's not a bomb....we wil...

Listen to the episode

June 7, 2020

Denali Brehmer // Alaska // 12

We have whiteboards to tell Hanna she sucks, alcohol baskets on the deck, and moms hiding in the pantry? I guess we have a little bit of everything! We also have a crazy story about Denali Brehmer who was offered a lot of c...

Listen to the episode

May 31, 2020

Marie Noe // Pennsylvania // 11

Megan almost threw this whole story out, but apparently decided, everybody needs to hear the awful story of, Marie Noe. Hanna picked the story, so if you're mad, yell at her! Marie Noe definitely was not the best mom in the w...

Listen to the episode

May 24, 2020

Eugene Butler and Kathy Bonderson // North Dakota // 10

Megan decided that she wanted to share our super embarrassing stories from our childhood again, so now you get to hear about our baby egg, that doesn't have a great ending.....much like the stories about Eugene Butler and Kat...

Listen to the episode

May 24, 2020

James Byrd Jr. and Sam Bass // Texas // 9

This week, you get to hear how creepy Megan and Hanna were as children! With a little bit of Blue's Clues and Veggie Tales sprinkled on top! We eventually get to the real story, which unfortunately, isn't a laughing matter....

Listen to the episode

May 16, 2020

The Phantom Barber and Witch Dance // Mississippi // 8

Keep your windows locked as we talk about the light hearted case, so Megan claims, of the Phantom Barber of Pascagoula in M-I-S-S-I-S-S-I-P-P-I, or you might just wake up to the soothing sound of scissors in your ears tonight...

Listen to the episode

May 10, 2020

Crystal Rogers // Kentucky // 7

What do black paint and dog treats have in common? Neither Hanna nor Isaac should be in charge of them ever again. But if you’re having a bad day like them, grab some Taco Bell….or dream it?? While you’re at it, turn the v...

Listen to the episode

May 2, 2020

The Purple Gang // Michigan // 6

Have you heard of the Purple Gang from Michigan? Neither have we and this shit is BANANAS! If you love mob history, then buckle up and hold onto your hair, it just may fall off! We will discuss the Lindbergh baby kidnappin...

Listen to the episode

April 26, 2020

Audrey Hilley // Alabama // 5

Put on a onesie and take a bite out of someone's leg....or maybe just a drumstick. This twisted adventure is about a woman named Audrey Hilley from Alabama and is full of fires, poisonings, and injections. It even has a nig...

Listen to the episode

April 18, 2020

Abraham Lincoln // Washington // 4

In this episode, we will warm up our vocal cords with shots of 99 Bananas and Sing Amazing Grace to a body. Did you know there was a plan to murder three people on the night of Abraham Lincoln’s assassination? Or were you t...

Listen to the episode

April 4, 2020

Jessica Chambers // Tennessee // 3

On this episode, you will hear the wonderful sounds of us eating pickles.....slowly.....just kidding! Or are we?! Nineteen-year-old Jessica Chambers was a beaming cheerleader found burning next to her car which was also on ...

Listen to the episode

March 29, 2020

Jodi Huisentruit // Iowa // 2

Jodi Huisentruit was a beautiful television news anchor for KIMT in Iowa. She vanished one morning and there were signs of a struggle outside her apartment. Was she abducted by someone she knew? Could this be drug related?...

Listen to the episode

March 28, 2020

Joseph Taborsky // Connecticut // 1

Joseph Taborsky "Mad Dog" was a murderer in Connecticut who was sent to death row not once, but twice for different crimes. https://drinkingthecoolaid.com/ Leave a review: RateThisPodcast.com/ coolaid

Listen to the episode