Season 1

Feb. 20, 2022

Elizabeth Smart // 98 // Part 1 // Survivor

Elizabeth Smart was abducted from her home when she was 14 years old by Brian David Mitchell. Brian and his wife, Wanda Barzee, held her captive for nine months until she was rescued by police on March 12th, 2003. In 2011, ...

Listen to the episode

Feb. 13, 2022

Dolly Oesterreich // 97 // The man in the attic

Walburga Oesterreich (Dolly) married a wealthy man named Fred. When she was 33, she was introduced to 17-year-old Otto Sanhuber, who worked at her husband's factory. Dolly invited Otto to her home to "fix her sewing machine...

Listen to the episode

Jan. 30, 2022

James Holmes // Part 2 // 95 // Mass Shooting

James Eagan Holmes is a mass murderer responsible for the 2012 Aurora, Colorado shooting at a Century 16 movie theater on July 20th, 2012. He didn't have any known criminal background prior to the shooting, but his behavior ...

Listen to the episode

Jan. 23, 2022

James Holmes // Part 1 // 94 // Mass Shooting

James Eagan Holmes is a mass murderer responsible for the 2012 Aurora, Colorado shooting at a Century 16 movie theater on July 20th, 2012. He didn't have any known criminal background prior to the shooting, but his behavior ...

Listen to the episode

Jan. 16, 2022

Typhoid Mary // 93 // Mary Mallon

Mrs. Warren's family came down with Typhoid fever shortly after hiring their new cook, Mary Mallon. It was soon discovered that Mary was a carrier of typhoid even though she appeared to be healthy. In the 1900's, people did...

Listen to the episode

Jan. 9, 2022

Dorothy's ruby slippers // 92 // Stolen

In 1970, MGM's wardrobe department decided to auction off their props and costumes. Kent Warner, gave one pair of Judy Garland's ruby slippers to be auctioned and he stole the rest. A collector named Michael Shaw ended up w...

Listen to the episode

Jan. 2, 2022

The Wizard of Oz secrets // 91 // dark history

The Wizard of Oz is an iconic movie with many dark secrets and rumors. During the film, several people were injured, the paint was toxic, the snow was made of asbestos, and the costumes were extremely difficult to wear. The...

Listen to the episode

Dec. 26, 2021

The Waverly Hills Sanatorium // 90 // Haunted

The Waverly Hills Sanatorium is located in Louisville, Kentucky. It was opened as a two-story hospital for tuberculosis patients in 1910 and was over capacity right away. The facility expanded and once you were sent there, ...

Listen to the episode

Dec. 19, 2021

Dennis Rader // 89 // BTK // Part 3

Dennis Rader known as BTK (Bind, Torture, Kill) murdered 10 people in Kansas. He sent letters, poems, and dolls to the police and local news stations detailing his murders because he liked the cat and mouse game. Dennis end...

Listen to the episode

Dec. 12, 2021

Dennis Rader // 88 // BTK // Part 2

Dennis Rader known as BTK (Bind, Torture, Kill) murdered 10 people in Kansas. He sent letters, poems, and dolls to the police and local news stations detailing his murders because he liked the cat and mouse game. Dennis end...

Listen to the episode

Dec. 5, 2021

Dennis Rader // 87 // BTK // Part 1

Dennis Rader known as BTK (Bind, Torture, Kill) murdered 10 people in Kansas. He sent letters, poems, and dolls to the police and local news stations detailing his murders because he liked the cat and mouse game. Dennis end...

Listen to the episode

Nov. 28, 2021

Cinnamon Brown // 86 // Part 2

Linda Brown was murdered on March 19th, 1985 and the main suspects were the people that lived in the home. Everyone had different stories about what took place and Linda's stepdaughter, 14-year-old Cinnamon Brown was convict...

Listen to the episode

Nov. 21, 2021

Cinnamon Brown // 85 // Part 1

Linda Brown was murdered on March 19th, 1985 and the main suspects were the people that lived in the home. Everyone had different stories about what took place and Linda's stepdaughter, 14-year-old Cinnamon Brown was convict...

Listen to the episode

Nov. 14, 2021

Martha Moxley // 84 // Part 2 // Unsolved

15-year-old Martha Moxley lived in Greenwich, Connecticut. On October 30th, 1975, the kids in the Belle Haven neighborhood celebrated Mischief Night. Martha was last seen hanging out at the Skakel residence and she was murd...

Listen to the episode

Nov. 7, 2021

Martha Moxley // 83 // Part 1 // Unsolved

15-year-old Martha Moxley lived in Greenwich, Connecticut. On October 30th, 1975, the kids in the Belle Haven neighborhood celebrated Mischief Night. Martha was last seen hanging out at the Skakel residence and she was murd...

Listen to the episode

Oct. 31, 2021

Villisca Axe Murders // 82 // Haunted

On June 9th, 1912, the Moore family went to an evening church service. They allowed their daughter to bring the Stillinger girls home for a sleepover, but things went horribly wrong. All eight people were hacked to death wi...

Listen to the episode

Oct. 24, 2021

Lemp Mansion // 81 // family curse

You think you have bad luck?? Wait until you hear the story about the Lemps! After becoming millionaires in the brewing business, and one of the biggest brewing companies in St.Louis, MO, their luck quickly declined. With man...

Listen to the episode

Oct. 17, 2021

Black Eyed Kids // 80 // Paranormal // Part 2

The Black Eyed Kids are mysterious beings that look like kids that are between the ages of 6 to 16. They will usually appear at night and seem to show up when an adult is alone. The kids can come in groups of two or more and ...

Listen to the episode

Oct. 10, 2021

Black Eyed Kids // 79 // Paranormal // Part 1

The Black Eyed Kids are mysterious beings that look like kids that are between the ages of 6 to 16. They will usually appear at night and seem to show up when an adult is alone. The kids can come in groups of two or more and ...

Listen to the episode

Oct. 3, 2021

Whaley House // 78 // Supernatural // Haunted

The Whaley House is located in San Diego, California and is considered to be one of the most haunted houses in America. The land was purchased in 1855, but many people believe that the home was destined to be haunted before ...

Listen to the episode

Sept. 26, 2021

Tom and Jackie Hawks // 77 // Overboard

Tom and Jackie Hawks bought a boat named Well Deserved and they were living their dream life. They found out that their son was going to be a father and they decided it was time to sell their boat so they could be close to t...

Listen to the episode

Sept. 19, 2021

Busby Stoop Chair // 76 // CURSE

Thomas Busby owned an inn/pub. One day, his father-in-law, Daniel, sat in his favorite chair. The men got in a fight and Tom ended up murdering Dan that night. Thomas was sentenced to death by hanging and he would be dippe...

Listen to the episode

Sept. 12, 2021

Moberly Jourdain Incident // 75 // Time Slip

Charlotte Moberly and Eleanor Jourdain took a trip together and toured Versailles in August of 1901. They walked along the paths and ended up at the Petit Trianon. They saw a few people wearing old time clothes and both lad...

Listen to the episode

Aug. 29, 2021

Frederick Valentich // 74 // Disappearance

On the evening of October 21st, 1978, Frederick Valentich piloted a plane over the Bass Strait and planned to land in King Island. He radioed the Melbourne Flight Service to let them know there was a large aircraft passing o...

Listen to the episode

Aug. 22, 2021

Mary Bell // 73 // Child murderer // Part 3

Someone was preying on children in Tyne, England. The killer was eventually dubbed the Tyneside Strangler. This story is terrifying for many reasons, but the scariest part is that the killer, was a child herself. Mary Flora ...

Listen to the episode

Aug. 15, 2021

Mary Bell // 72 // Child murderer // Part 2

Someone was preying on children in Tyne, England. The killer was eventually dubbed the Tyneside Strangler. This story is terrifying for many reasons, but the scariest part is that the killer, was a child herself. Mary Flora ...

Listen to the episode

Aug. 8, 2021

Mary Bell // 71 // Child murderer // Part 1

Someone was preying on children in Tyne, England. The killer was eventually dubbed the Tyneside Strangler. This story is terrifying for many reasons, but the scariest part is that the killer, was a child herself. Mary Flora ...

Listen to the episode

Aug. 1, 2021

Lesandro Guzman-Feliz // 70 // Junior

Lesandro Guzman-Feliz was a 15-year-old who went by the name Junior. On June 20th, 2018, a group of men from the Trinitarios Los Sures gang drug Junior out of a Bodega. The gang brutally murdered Junior with knives and a m...

Listen to the episode

July 25, 2021

The Silent Twins // 69 // June and Jennifer Gibbons

June and Jennifer Gibbons were twins that shared a very unique bond. They both refused to speak to other people, including their family. The girls desperately wanted to be individuals and be separated, but they couldn't see...

Listen to the episode

July 18, 2021

The Papin Sisters // 68 // Murderous Maids

Two sisters, Lea and Christine Papin were live-in maids for the Lancelin family. They had worked for the family for many years, but one day, things went terribly wrong. Lea and Christine brutally murdered two women, Leonie ...

Listen to the episode

July 11, 2021

Pee Wee Gaskins // 67 // Serial killer // Part 2

Pee Wee Gaskins began burglarizing homes and getting into trouble when he was very young, so he was sent to reform school. Over the years, his crimes kept escalating and he started torturing and murdering people. He got awa...

Listen to the episode

July 4, 2021

Pee Wee Gaskins // 66 // Serial killer // Part 1

Pee Wee Gaskins began burglarizing homes and getting into trouble when he was very young, so he was sent to reform school. Over the years, his crimes kept escalating and he started torturing and murdering people. He got awa...

Listen to the episode

June 27, 2021

The Widower// Tom Randolph // 65

Tom Randolph called 911 to report that his wife had been murdered by an intruder. When police began looking into this, they realized that Tom had been married 6 times and 4 of his wives were dead. https://www.drinkingthecool...

Listen to the episode

June 20, 2021

Kedarie Johnson // 64 // hate crime

Kedarie Johnson was a gender fluid teen with a BIG personality. He was murdered on the night of March 2nd, 2016. Even though this looks and feels like a hate crime, Iowa doesn't cover gender fluidity as a hate crime. https:...

Listen to the episode

June 13, 2021

Rey Rivera // 63 // unsolved

Rey Rivera moved to Baltimore with his wife to work for Stansberry & Associates. On May 16th, 2006, Rey took a call and left the house in a hurry. His body was discovered in the Belvedere hotel and some people believe that ...

Listen to the episode

June 6, 2021

Nathaniel Bar-Jonah // 62 // suspected serial killer and cannibal

Nathaniel Bar-Jonah showed signs of abnormal behavior at a very young age. He assaulted many children over the years and is suspected of murder as well. Friends say that Nathaniel served them strange tasting meat at parties...

Listen to the episode

May 30, 2021

Jennifer Fairgate // 61 // unsolved

This story starts with a question, but ends with more. What happened in room 2805? On May 31st, 1995, a woman who went by the name Jennifer Fairgate checked into Room 2805 of the Oslo Plaza Hotel in Norway. She was discover...

Listen to the episode

May 23, 2021

Skinwalker Ranch // 60 // Paranormal

Skinwalker ranch is recognized as the most scientifically studied paranormal hotspot on the planet. There has been UFO sightings, poltergeist activity, cattle mutilations, odd injuries, transient radiation spikes, crop circle...

Listen to the episode

May 16, 2021

Heather Elvis // 59 // Disappearance

On December 17th, 2013, Heather Elvis landed a new job in cosmetology and she was going on a date with a new guy. Two days later, her car abandoned car was discovered. When police looked through Heather's phone records, the...

Listen to the episode

May 9, 2021

The Pollock Twins // 58 // Reincarnation

John and Florence Pollock had two daughters, Joanna, and Jacqueline. The girls were hit by a car and killed when they were very young, but their father always believed they would be reincarnated. Florence did get pregnant a...

Listen to the episode

May 2, 2021

The Sallie House // Kansas // 57

The Sallie House is located in Kansas and is known for extreme paranormal activity. There have been reports of fires, strange noises, cold spots, ghosts, scratches, and so much more. Allegedly, there is a little girl named ...

Listen to the episode

March 28, 2021

Lyda Southard // Idaho // 56

Lyda Southard was known as Flypaper Lyda, Lady Bluebeard, and the black widow. She married several men and they all kept mysteriously dying. It was eventually discovered that some of the bodies contained traces of arsenic p...

Listen to the episode

March 21, 2021

Bennington Triangle // Vermont // 55

The Bennington Triangle has had several disappearances and oddities over the years. Native American legends say the land is cursed because all four winds met one spot in an eternal struggle. They also have legends about a man-eating stone. The Glastenbury Mountain is said to have trails that stop part way up and a deafening silence. There are several theories about the disappearances such as: a serial killer, alien abductions, wormholes, hypothermia, and even the Bennington Monster.

Listen to the episode

March 14, 2021

April Kauffman // New Jersey // 54

April Kauffman was a popular, vivacious, and provocative talk show host who advocated for veterans. On May 10th, 2012, she was discovered shot dead in her bedroom. April's daughter, Kim Pack, felt that her step-father was ...

Listen to the episode

March 7, 2021

Binions // Nevada // 53

Benny Binion was an American gambling icon, career criminal, and convicted murderer who established illegal gambling operations. He moved his operations to Las Vegas and opened Binion's Horseshoe Casino. When he opened his ...

Listen to the episode

Feb. 28, 2021

Jane Prichard // Delaware and Gabby's Bones // Wyoming // 52

Jane Prichard was conducting research on a summer vine for college. She travelled to Blackbird State Forest for two summers to watch and track the progress of the plant. On September 19th, 1986, Jane drove to a friend's pla...

Listen to the episode

Feb. 21, 2021

The Bleeding House // Georgia // 51

On September 8th, 1987, Minnie Winston found bloodstains all over her home. The blood didn't belong to her or her husband and they called the police. During the investigation, police couldn't find the source of the blood an...

Listen to the episode

Feb. 14, 2021

Lisa Au // Hawaii // 50

Lisa Au had dinner with her boyfriend on January 20th, 1982 and never made it home that night. The next day, her car was discovered, and 10 days later, her body was found too. This case sent fear and shock waves through the...

Listen to the episode

Feb. 7, 2021

Alferd Packer // Colorado // 49

In November, 1873, 21 men headed for the gold field in Breckenridge, Colorado. Their guide, Alferd Packer, ended up being terrible with directions. The weather was awful and the men ran out of provisions pretty fast. They ...

Listen to the episode

Jan. 31, 2021

Josh Woodruff // Louisiana // 48

On January 1st, 2016, Josh Woodruff was murdered in New Orleans. He was struck by a black sedan with tinted windows that was traveling at a high rate of speed and never stopped. His body was trapped under the vehicle as it ...

Listen to the episode