True Crime Episodes

June 7, 2020

Denali Brehmer // Alaska // 12

We have whiteboards to tell Hanna she sucks, alcohol baskets on the deck, and moms hiding in the pantry? I guess we have a little bit of everything! We also have a crazy story about Denali Brehmer who was offered a lot of c...

Listen to the episode

May 31, 2020

Marie Noe // Pennsylvania // 11

Megan almost threw this whole story out, but apparently decided, everybody needs to hear the awful story of, Marie Noe. Hanna picked the story, so if you're mad, yell at her! Marie Noe definitely was not the best mom in the w...

Listen to the episode

May 24, 2020

Eugene Butler and Kathy Bonderson // North Dakota // 10

Megan decided that she wanted to share our super embarrassing stories from our childhood again, so now you get to hear about our baby egg, that doesn't have a great ending.....much like the stories about Eugene Butler and Kat...

Listen to the episode

May 24, 2020

James Byrd Jr. and Sam Bass // Texas // 9

This week, you get to hear how creepy Megan and Hanna were as children! With a little bit of Blue's Clues and Veggie Tales sprinkled on top! We eventually get to the real story, which unfortunately, isn't a laughing matter....

Listen to the episode

May 16, 2020

The Phantom Barber and Witch Dance // Mississippi // 8

Keep your windows locked as we talk about the light hearted case, so Megan claims, of the Phantom Barber of Pascagoula in M-I-S-S-I-S-S-I-P-P-I, or you might just wake up to the soothing sound of scissors in your ears tonight...

Listen to the episode

May 10, 2020

Crystal Rogers // Kentucky // 7

What do black paint and dog treats have in common? Neither Hanna nor Isaac should be in charge of them ever again. But if you’re having a bad day like them, grab some Taco Bell….or dream it?? While you’re at it, turn the v...

Listen to the episode

May 2, 2020

The Purple Gang // Michigan // 6

Have you heard of the Purple Gang from Michigan? Neither have we and this shit is BANANAS! If you love mob history, then buckle up and hold onto your hair, it just may fall off! We will discuss the Lindbergh baby kidnappin...

Listen to the episode

April 26, 2020

Audrey Hilley // Alabama // 5

Put on a onesie and take a bite out of someone's leg....or maybe just a drumstick. This twisted adventure is about a woman named Audrey Hilley from Alabama and is full of fires, poisonings, and injections. It even has a nig...

Listen to the episode

April 18, 2020

Abraham Lincoln // Washington // 4

In this episode, we will warm up our vocal cords with shots of 99 Bananas and Sing Amazing Grace to a body. Did you know there was a plan to murder three people on the night of Abraham Lincoln’s assassination? Or were you t...

Listen to the episode

April 4, 2020

Jessica Chambers // Tennessee // 3

On this episode, you will hear the wonderful sounds of us eating pickles.....slowly.....just kidding! Or are we?! Nineteen-year-old Jessica Chambers was a beaming cheerleader found burning next to her car which was also on ...

Listen to the episode

March 29, 2020

Jodi Huisentruit // Iowa // 2

Jodi Huisentruit was a beautiful television news anchor for KIMT in Iowa. She vanished one morning and there were signs of a struggle outside her apartment. Was she abducted by someone she knew? Could this be drug related?...

Listen to the episode

March 28, 2020

Joseph Taborsky // Connecticut // 1

Joseph Taborsky "Mad Dog" was a murderer in Connecticut who was sent to death row not once, but twice for different crimes. https://drinkingthecoolaid.com/ Leave a review: RateThisPodcast.com/ coolaid

Listen to the episode